Alright! I've been waiting years for this sequel and the time has finally came.
Black Phone 2 is a supernatural horror movie and the sequel to 2021's The Black Phone. Blumhouse Productions and Crooked Highway produced with Universal Pictures distributing. Scott Derrickson returns to direct and write the story along with his frequent writing collaborator C. Robert Cargill.
The story is, it's been four years since Finney survived his terrifying encounter with the notorious child serial killer The Grabber. Then one day his psychic sister Gwen starts having dreams of The Grabber and him killing more children. They both quickly realize he's back and is seeking vengeance.
Initial Reaction
The reason for why I wanted to see this is as simple as it gets. The first film was really good and I had a lot of fun with it. So when the sequel got an official trailer, I was set and ready to go.
Cons
I've got nothing.
Middle Ground
It's the pacing. While there are times when the movies goes by at a good pace, oftentimes it does slow down because the characters go into an exposition dump to explain the more supernatural elements of the story. Which is understandable because while there was supernatural elements in the first, this cranks it up a lot. So while it's good to have some explanation to things it still felt like those elements could've been told at a better pace that way the runtime didn't suffer.
Pros
Let's first start with the scary stuff. While the violence is intense I felt as though the more scary was the feeling that it gave you. First there's Derrickson's use of Super 8 footage. While grainy fuzzy 80's home video footage can give nostalgia to some, Black Phone 2 does an excellent job making you feel unnerved by it. But the best aspect to me was the location. You don't get that claustrophobic feeling like you did with the first, because the characters this time around are a camp. But for the most part you get a feeling of isolation. Finn, Gwen, and the others have to wait for somebody to come, but it's still hard to call for help because the roads have been closed due to a snowstorm and they can't call for help on a phone. But even when the sense of isolation is gone you still have Ethan Hawke's The Grabber to worry about. Whether he's there or not you always have this need to look over your shoulder because you can't help but have this feeling of being watched. Now I want to give credit to the story. Unlike the first movie where Gwen was a supporting character, this time around she's the main one. She has a really good arc where she has to come to terms with her psychic abilities and learns they're not some curse but a gift. But she also has an arc where she has to go full sister mode and call out Finn for not dealing with his problems in a more healthy way. Speaking of Finn, while still playing main character he also has great stories going for him. Firstly we see him dealing with his PTSD in some unhealthy ways. Smoking pot, getting into fights at school, and the standard of not wanting to talking about and just move on as quickly as possible. But the other aspect is him being a protective older brother to Gwen. Whether the odds are stacked against him or not, he's knows it's his job to protect his sister. But I also want to praise the ending. Without giving any spoilers I will say that last phone call is a great emotional payoff. My last praise goes to the performances. Now Ethan Hawke as The Grabber isn't physically in the movie all that much, but while he's physically performance is good, I think he's chilling Grabber voice is amazing. He killed in the first and this is no different. Then there's Mason Thames. While Mason does bring out Finn's edge in more rageful moments, I thought he also brought a great quiet intensity as well. Then there's Madeleine McGraw who I'm not gonna be surprised if she gets a ton of praise. She acts as the heart of the movie, and does a fantastic job bringing out Gwen's journey from frightened sister to someone being more defiant.
While there's some pacing issues Black Phone 2 still offers some very fun scares.
My final rating is, Good.
Yeah wasn't quite up there with the first but unlike some sequels it still has a lot to give. But that's all for now. Come back on Monday, Oct 20th, for a brand new Fan Film Mondays. For that one it'll be about Friday The 13th. Until then, enjoy the rest of your day.